Letters to the Editors / Lettres à la rédaction


Georgetown University, Washington D.C., Thursday, May 8th 1997
Professor R. Bensky

Dear Colleagues,

How may I express my deep pleasure upon reading the masterful and perceptive review granted my book in this new issue of AS/SA? Colleagues here at Georgetown are also most pleased and will, no doubt, pay very careful attention to your journal in the future.

I was especially gratified by the fact that the central paradigm of my study, ie. Dionysian ontogenesis as production of Mask in "the trans-historic now" received a full explicitation and that it was further deemed to offer an epistemological reconciliation between the paradigmatic propositions of Ubersfeld and Sarrazac. This is most felicitous, since, clearly, I had no prior knowledge of the "debate" which would prove central to the problematics of your issue.
However, beyond the "re-reading" of Dionysus, I was most impressed by the reviewer's dexterity in seizing the sometimes oblique structural coherence of my research, as one moves from one plot to the next in this aptly-termed "garden of vignettes." (The only area of ground whose specificity was perhaps investigated a little rapidly being that of Laou, inasmuch as the question of race - the theme of "negre-blanc" - is paramount and that my chapter on this particular writer validates acutely the Sarrazac side of the hermeneutic equation, namely, his central concern with the Other. Having said that, I also realize that bringing the racial issue into focus might have unbalanced the general economy of the review and forced the reviewer into thorny dialectical considerations leading away from mythography).
Concerning the one caveat expressed most courteously by the reviewer, ie. the matter of lexicon, all I can say in response is that I've undoubtedly been dwelling excessively on the writings of the likes of Sibony, Ouaknin and Maldiney, in whom one finds great freedom in what Ouaknin, basing his audacities on Talmudic word-play, calls "hidouch" or "innovation sémantique." Cela dit, the warning to the reader is appropriate and I am aware of the risks involved in stepping too far away from "les mots de la tribu."
Once again, thank you for this "traitement en profondeur" of my work and allow me to conclude with the sincere hope that our paths will cross again in the near future.

Bien cordialement à vous,

Roger-Daniel Bensky





Page - 1     Page + 1


AS/SA n°3 (05.1997) : Page 173



© 1997 AS/SA

E-mail to the editors
Pour écrire à la rédaction

05.05.1997